Negative Inserts: When to Switch and How to Save Money

BeyondMachining

Technical Director - OYYU Tools
H-M Supporter - Commercial Member
A lot of guys stick exclusively to positive inserts (like CCMT or DCMT) when they start out because they take light cuts easily and don't load up smaller lathes.

While positive inserts are great for low-rigidity setups, sticking only to positive tooling means you're leaving a lot of edge life—and money—on the table when turning solid steel or cast iron.

Here is a quick refresher on when to run positive vs. negative geometries and why it matters:

Positive Inserts (CCMT, DCMT, TCMT)

Geometry: Built with a built-in clearance angle (usually 7 degrees) underneath the cutting edge.

Best for: Small benchtop lathes, light finishing passes, internal boring bars, and soft materials like aluminum or brass.

Trade-off: You only get half the edges per insert (a CCMT only gives you 2 cutting corners). Because the edge is sharper and thinner, it chips more easily under heavy interrupted cuts.

Negative Inserts (CNMG, TNMG, WNMG)

Geometry: The cutting edge is perpendicular (90 degrees) to the top and bottom faces, relying on the tool holder's pocket angle to provide clearance.

Best for: Heavy roughing, interrupted cuts, cast iron, and medium-to-large CNC or rigid manual lathes.

Trade-off: Requires more machine horsepower and rigid setups because of higher cutting resistance.

The Big Advantage: Double the cutting edges! A CNMG insert gives you 4 usable corners, and a WNMG gives you 6. That instantly cuts your consumable costs in half on heavy stock removal.

When should you switch?
If your lathe has enough rigidity and motor power to take at least a 1.5mm to 2mm (0.060"+) depth of cut in steel, switching your main roughing holder to a negative style like CNMG or WNMG will save you a ton on insert costs over time. But if you're turning thin-walled tubing or slender shafts without a tailstock, stick with positive CCMT to prevent chatter.

What is your default setup for general steel roughing—do you stick with 2-corner positive inserts for convenience, or do you run 6-corner WNMGs to keep running costs down?

(If you are looking to expand your setup with rigid negative tool holders or cost-effective carbide inserts, feel free to check out our catalog at www.cnchome-beyond.com.)
 
I got a trick for best of both. My machine, 10EE, is plenty rigid but I seldom make production DOCs and feeds.

I have found CNMG inserts made for AL work really well on most steels while still getting the extra edges. Plus top end brands go cheap on flebay for the patient.

<edit> if one looks close a CNMG for AL actually is a positive rake insert
 
Last edited:
I got a trick for best of both. My machine, 10EE, is plenty rigid but I seldom make production DOCs and feeds.

I have found CNMG inserts made for AL work really well on most steels while still getting the extra edges. Plus top end brands go cheap on flebay for the patient.

<edit> if one looks close a CNMG for AL actually is a positive rake insert
@Karl_T First off, love the Monarch 10EE—absolute benchmark of a machine!

That aluminum-geometry CNMG trick is fantastic. Because those AL inserts are precision-ground with that mirror finish and deep high-rake top geometry, they cut steel like butter with almost zero resistance. Perfect for light-to-medium passes when you want to keep cutting forces low without giving up the 4 usable edges of a CNMG.

As long as you aren't slamming into heavy interrupted cuts on hard steel, running polished AL geometries on steel is one of the best kept secrets for a mirror finish!
 
There is the lathe pocket angle and the insert leading edge profile/rake, it is not a simple answerer on how this combination is used and it is also specific to turning conditions which are multiple factors. As a general rule negative rake molded inserts are meant for much heavier and rigid machines then most hobbyist would most likely have in their shop, and those that have heavier machines typically already know a fair amount about what inserts work for the specific machine/application. The material you are turning is a big factor as to what insert you use as well as the profile required and the holder used.

My current lathe is 2500 lbs. and moderately rigid as far as 13x40 lathes go, I do use a WNMG with ground edge uncoated inserts in aluminum and light cuts in alloy steel, I also use them in steel with molded edge inserts, but my lathe does much better with neutral rake type inserts in steel. Get into the tougher machining materials that want deeper DOC and feed, I would not consider negative rake insert such as CNMG types unless I had a few more Hp and another 1000+ lbs. A negative rake uncoated aluminum rated insert wouldn't make it very far in the alloy steels I turn. Inserts for SS and exotic metals tend to have a sharper edge with more positive rake, better coatings, chip breakers and are a good compromise in turning using neutral rake inserts such as CCMT. They also make various versions for finer cutting vs. interrupt turning. The insert profile and cutting angle/material approach may also dictate different type of insert properties.

Last but not least, how many cutting edges available is less of a factor if an insert doesn't last or perform well. If an insert is not working for you, then move on and find one that performs better and lasts in your application. Production environment is a whole different picture as to the performance usable life of an insert. When it comes to lathe inserts for boring, I would not recommend a negative rake insert, and the insert properties required are quite different.
 
There is the lathe pocket angle and the insert leading edge profile/rake, it is not a simple answerer on how this combination is used and it is also specific to turning conditions which are multiple factors. As a general rule negative rake molded inserts are meant for much heavier and rigid machines then most hobbyist would most likely have in their shop, and those that have heavier machines typically already know a fair amount about what inserts work for the specific machine/application. The material you are turning is a big factor as to what insert you use as well as the profile required and the holder used.

My current lathe is 2500 lbs. and moderately rigid as far as 13x40 lathes go, I do use a WNMG with ground edge uncoated inserts in aluminum and light cuts in alloy steel, I also use them in steel with molded edge inserts, but my lathe does much better with neutral rake type inserts in steel. Get into the tougher machining materials that want deeper DOC and feed, I would not consider negative rake insert such as CNMG types unless I had a few more Hp and another 1000+ lbs. A negative rake uncoated aluminum rated insert wouldn't make it very far in the alloy steels I turn. Inserts for SS and exotic metals tend to have a sharper edge with more positive rake, better coatings, chip breakers and are a good compromise in turning using neutral rake inserts such as CCMT. They also make various versions for finer cutting vs. interrupt turning. The insert profile and cutting angle/material approach may also dictate different type of insert properties.

Last but not least, how many cutting edges available is less of a factor if an insert doesn't last or perform well. If an insert is not working for you, then move on and find one that performs better and lasts in your application. Production environment is a whole different picture as to the performance usable life of an insert. When it comes to lathe inserts for boring, I would not recommend a negative rake insert, and the insert properties required are quite different.
@mksj That point about available cutting edges is spot on—having 6 usable corners on a WNMG doesn't mean much if the cutting forces cause chatter or ruin tool life on a lighter machine. Usability always comes before corner count.

Also completely agree on internal boring. Trying to force a negative rake insert down a deep bore on anything less than a massive industrial setup is just asking for deflection, bell-mouthing, or a jammed chip.

Really solid breakdown of how machine mass and horse power dictate tool geometry over paper specs. Appreciate the detailed real-world input!
 
Back
Top