Fly cutting on the mighty comet

sasanifab

Registered
Registered
Joined
Oct 3, 2020
Messages
80
So I build engines on the side, more specifically the 4g63 and Honda Variants. I took it upon myself to try to mill the head and the deck of the block. The issues I have I believe are related to rigidity. The iron block actually came out perfect. I’m having more issues with the head. I think it may be due to the fact that I dont have the proper Fixture for it and it’s rocking. If you look at the surface finish it looks scalloped. I’m looking for a mirror finish. Ive tried brazed on tooling and indexible tooling. Maybe hss ? What’s the best for aluminum ? What are guys doing to add rigidity to their mills ? This is a Mighty comet just over 2000lbs. I was thinking about adding sandbags to the base? I’m even considering bolting it to the concrete
 

Attachments

  • F0A4D649-4E8C-4C25-A02B-C6EB96D6A43A.jpeg
    F0A4D649-4E8C-4C25-A02B-C6EB96D6A43A.jpeg
    1.8 MB · Views: 203
  • 553C2CE6-F2F3-4DCC-A522-6BF886A21D51.jpeg
    553C2CE6-F2F3-4DCC-A522-6BF886A21D51.jpeg
    2.9 MB · Views: 208
  • FD993AED-1699-4081-A67C-827213A13316.jpeg
    FD993AED-1699-4081-A67C-827213A13316.jpeg
    1.6 MB · Views: 190
  • 21D2D935-884F-409A-A205-4B22BC49B752.jpeg
    21D2D935-884F-409A-A205-4B22BC49B752.jpeg
    1.4 MB · Views: 173
  • 7AE372EA-7CE9-4D8F-8C78-2E47F1F2764F.jpeg
    7AE372EA-7CE9-4D8F-8C78-2E47F1F2764F.jpeg
    1 MB · Views: 172
  • 32EB3033-743D-4C7E-BD55-62ECEC03A486.jpeg
    32EB3033-743D-4C7E-BD55-62ECEC03A486.jpeg
    1 MB · Views: 187
I would recommend Cobalt HSS with a tip radius of just a couple of thou and a feed rate of a couple of thou per rev. I see a lot of head/tool deflection on the interrupted cut on the head. The small tip radius with a shallow DoC and a slow feed rate will take a lot of the forces that cause deflection out of the picture. Also note: a bit of "character" on the head will help it grab the gasket.

But you need machine jacks under the head to support it from deflecting under the loads of machining.
You may or may not need to stiffen the machine to the floor.

While 2,000 pounds is heavy for a mill, it is chicken feed to machines designed to machine heads.
 
you are getting chatter!
as Mitch said, low doc's - large radius on the tool
you didn't mention whether you were machining wet or dry- machining wet may improve the surface finish
tool speed and machine wear, could be factors too
 
Ok that’s what I thought , the iron block came out perfect, the block was bolted directly to the table and is obviously a lot more rigid. I need to come up with a good way to support the head
 
Ok that’s what I thought , the iron block came out perfect, the block was bolted directly to the table and is obviously a lot more rigid. I need to come up with a good way to support the head

5-10 machinist jacks.
 
Block is good so no worries about weighing down mill.

How are you anchoring the head?

Bolts through spark plug holes maybe?

Aluminum requires a whole different cutter and "style "

Sometimes very slow speed whole sometimes fast.

The deep cuts tell me something is either moving or buildup on The cutter.

Dawn makes good coolant as it is slippery and cheap.

Garden sprayer makes application easy.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk
 
Cylinder heads are usually mounted to the mill table by front and rear surfaces of the head. Here is a good example of a homemade setup. Mike
I started to get into the cylinder head work a while back, and since I'm a cheap bastard...I made this rollover fixture.

c8d851b5.jpg


Angle plates from Enco, some blocks of scrapbinium, an old 327 crankshaft, and some bolts.
 
I found an awesome cmt insert that cuts likes butter, I just need to purchase an appropriate jig for the head
 
I've been surfacing aluminum cylinder heads with a flycutter on my South Bend VMM. Check the gibs on your ways for proper adjustment. This made a big difference on reducing chatter and improving surface finish for me.
 
I've been surfacing aluminum cylinder heads with a flycutter on my South Bend VMM. Check the gibs on your ways for proper adjustment. This made a big difference on reducing chatter and improving surface finish for me.
I was using a half ass way to secure the head to the table , the block finish came out perfect imo. I’d assume if my Gibs were out too I’d have issues with the block too no ?
 

Attachments

  • 2DA57484-F387-4BEE-8650-CDC9EE4CAD04.jpeg
    2DA57484-F387-4BEE-8650-CDC9EE4CAD04.jpeg
    1.4 MB · Views: 137
  • 2E8A3CB4-B593-44EC-AF23-7AFE0198F3E6.jpeg
    2E8A3CB4-B593-44EC-AF23-7AFE0198F3E6.jpeg
    1.8 MB · Views: 127
  • IMG_6276.MOV
    23.9 MB
  • 1B7F409D-E793-47F6-A7AC-75390456584C.jpeg
    1B7F409D-E793-47F6-A7AC-75390456584C.jpeg
    1.6 MB · Views: 142
Back
Top