Talk me out of a used Harbor Freight knee mill

MontanaLon

Registered
Registered
Joined
Mar 15, 2019
Messages
702
I have been looking for a mill for 6 months and have found that anything American or European made in a size I can break down and move into the basement is out of my price range. Clausing 8520's are running about $2,000 for a bare machine and more with any tooling. And at that price they sell fast.

I recently located a used Harbor Freight knee mill with a very basic set of tooling for $1,000. It is about 3 years old and used very little. Only mark on it is on the back of the belt cover where it was lifted too high while entering a garage and caught the door frame and popped the bondo off. Guy says he bought it to machine 80% AR lowers and after all his friends had AR's he ran out of stuff to do with it. Tools include a 4" USA made swivel vise, hold down kit, half dozen collets, maybe 4 end mills, drill chuck, face mill and some indicators and calipers.

Everything on the machine operates smoothly, all handwheels are present, quill coarse and fine feed operate, quill spins smoothly under power.

So tell me why I shouldn't buy it. I believe it will do what I need it to do and other than being an import it is the size I was looking for at 1/2 the price.

I realize it will be somewhat of a project bringing it to a point where it will work well and I am OK with that. I will have to disassemble it to get it into the basement anyway and figure the current owner never broke it down and cleaned it up when he got it originally so it probably has casting sand and cosmoline in bad places so breaking it down will probably be a good thing.
 

Latinrascalrg1

Registered
Registered
Joined
Dec 9, 2016
Messages
1,131
I agree, so long as you are able and willing to get it cleaned up and adjusted properly Im thinking you will be very happy with the purchase....if you're not gonna buy it im sure someone on here would be interested in they are close enough!
 

Ulma Doctor

Infinitely Curious
H-M Platinum Supporter
Joined
Feb 2, 2013
Messages
2,223
if you are looking to doing similar in nature to projects as the previous owner did, you'll be happy to have the HF machine
ar lowers are aluminum and easier to machine than blocks of steel
but if light cuts are taken, workable solutions can be made.
the tolerances and quality control were loose on a large number of mainland china machines
but on the positive side, you know it works, and has only had one owner= is a good deal
 

pstemari

H-M Supporter - Gold Member
H-M Supporter Gold Member
Joined
May 18, 2015
Messages
531
Yeah, if someone has been successfully machining AR lowers, that's a decent sign the machine is reasonable tight. I imagine you'll need to lock the quill when milling,

Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk
 

Latinrascalrg1

Registered
Registered
Joined
Dec 9, 2016
Messages
1,131
Yeah, if someone has been successfully machining AR lowers, that's a decent sign the machine is reasonable tight. I imagine you'll need to lock the quill when milling,

Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk
I wouldnt use that as my "Benchmark" to claim anything good about any machine only simply because finishing an ar80% is not huge challange! It can be done quite easily and many times if care is taken, very nicely as well, with little more then a hand drill or router along with a few other basic tools. Plus we do not know the skill level or if there was any "abuse" due to lack of knowledge on their part.
 

Aaron_W

H-M Supporter - Sustaining Member
H-M Platinum Supporter
Joined
Nov 14, 2016
Messages
1,698
If you are looking for an 8520 sized machine, those HF mills are essentially copies of the 8520, with a few improvements. R8 instead of MT2, a 1 1/2hp motor vs the Clausings 3/4hp and a slightly larger table / travel. Those are the good points, it is probably safe to assume the HF's fit and finish is lacking even compared to a well used Clausing.


$1000 isn't a bad price so long as nothing is wrong with it. New the bare machine, no vise or tooling is $2000 + delivery fees and taxes. For $1000 you are basically comparing to bench mills and mill-drills. This gives you a decent mill and if you later find a Clausing or the similar sized Rockwell you can almost certainly turn around and make your money back selling it to someone else. It also lets you know if a mill that size will make you happy, if yes keep looking, if no, you know you need to start looking for something larger. Personally if I had found that deal before the mill I have now, I would have jumped on it.

I have a Clausing 8520, and got it into my basement by myself using only an engine hoist and a garden trailer. I broke it down into 5 main parts, the head, motor, column, table and base. You should be able to do the same with that one, but the HF doesn't have the base, so one less thing. You will want to mount it on something to bring it up to a comfortable working height. Moving the column was the hardest since it is cast iron and weighs about 250lbs. I didn't have to worry about stairs so that is where the garden cart came in. The HF doesn't have a base, so you will need to find something to mount it on to bring it to a comfortable height.



Sorry, I was supposed to talk you out of buying it.



I assume this is the machine you are talking about?

Harbor Freight 6x26 mill
 
Last edited:

MontanaLon

Registered
Registered
Joined
Mar 15, 2019
Messages
702
If you are looking for an 8520 sized machine, those HF mills are essentially copies of the 8520, with a few improvements. R8 instead of MT2, a 1 1/2hp motor vs the Clausings 3/4hp and a slightly larger table / travel. Those are the good points, it is probably safe to assume the HF's fit and finish is lacking even compared to a well used Clausing.


$1000 isn't a bad price so long as nothing is wrong with it. New the bare machine, no vise or tooling is $2000 + delivery fees and taxes. For $1000 you are basically comparing to bench mills and mill-drills. This gives you a decent mill and if you later find a Clausing or the similar sized Rockwell you can almost certainly turn around and make your money back selling it to someone else. It also lets you know if a mill that size will make you happy, if yes keep looking, if no, you know you need to start looking for something larger. Personally if I had found that deal before the mill I have now, I would have jumped on it.

I have a Clausing 8520, and got it into my basement by myself using only an engine hoist and a garden trailer. I broke it down into 5 main parts, the head, motor, column, table and base. You should be able to do the same with that one, but the HF doesn't have the base, so one less thing. You will want to mount it on something to bring it up to a comfortable working height. Moving the column was the hardest since it is cast iron and weighs about 250lbs. I didn't have to worry about stairs so that is where the garden cart came in. The HF doesn't have a base, so you will need to find something to mount it on to bring it to a comfortable height.



Sorry, I was supposed to talk you out of buying it.



I assume this is the machine you are talking about?

Harbor Freight 6x26 mill
That is indeed the very one. I may have to break it down a bit more than you did as I have to contend with stairs. I worked out a pretty good system to move the lathe bed in through the window and the column is probably a touch lighter than the bed was. If I ever build my own home it will have an elevator in it. A guy I know bought one of the vehicle lifts from a Walmart when they tore it down after building the new service center in the super center next door. He put it in a bump out of the basement foundation and has easy access to take even cars down there to work on them. When it isn't in use it has a roof over it so no water gets in.
 

Aaron_W

H-M Supporter - Sustaining Member
H-M Platinum Supporter
Joined
Nov 14, 2016
Messages
1,698
I'm not sure how much trouble it would be since I didn't do it, but I would think you can remove the knee without too much trouble. That would probably knock off another 50-60lbs. It would certainly make the column a bit less awkward. Other than that everything else was a load of 100lbs or less, not too bad for one person, and should be no problem with two.

If you buy this one, I'll be very curious to know how it works out. I have limited height in my shop so this size mill was an ideal size for me and I spent some time trying to find out about these HF mills. I was not able to find any comments on them good or bad which surprises me because it is a really nice size to bridge the gap between the larger mill/drills and knee mills like Millrite or the ubiquitous Bridgeports.
Even if it was a complete piece of junk, you would think people would comment to say so.

Good luck
 

markba633csi

Registered
Registered
Joined
Apr 30, 2015
Messages
6,120
If I'm not mistaken the head articulates on the Clausing whereas on the HF it doesnt. Also I'm pretty sure the leadscrews are something like 8 tpi on the HF machine
 
It can take up to an hour for ads to appear on the page. See our code implementation guide for more details. If you already have Auto ad code on your pages there's no need to replace it with this code
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock