PM-45M Spindle Seals Replacement

yegg

Registered
Registered
Joined
Nov 15, 2014
Messages
8
Ok, here it goes. I am an amateur machinist (not sure I even qualify on that title) and have had a PM-45M for several years now and love it (mostly). The following three (3) pictures are just a reference to the mill itself as there seem to be a few slightly different versions of the machine.

Front (head on) view.

0001_zps6481168f.jpg

Right side.

0002_zps18c04e6f.jpg

Left side.

0003_zpsc095a497.jpg

I never changed the oil before and decided to go whole hog now that I have had an oil leak for several months. I contacted Matt and he said it had to be the spindle seals and sent me a package of two. Below is a picture of the two seals as well as the package they came in. That way you can have the specs as well as a brand.

0004_zpsa2942b71.jpg

0005_zps7379d737.jpg

I read the sticky thread (http://www.hobby-machinist.com/showthread.php/15361-How-to-change-the-seals-on-the-PM45-Spindle) thoroughly and got ready to do this.

Welcome to my saga and a few more questions. Below are a few obligatory shots showing what we are dealing with. Everyone on the same page? ;)

Did anyone notice my first mistake from the pictures above? That's right....I have a chuck installed still. Doh! Step 1 - Make sure you do not have any tooling installed and go ahead and set the draw bar aside as well.

The motor shroud comes off next.

0006_zpsfce7a31f.jpg

There are also two screws in the control box affixed to the left side of the mill. All six (6) screws are the same size.

0007_zpsad265121.jpg

For whatever reason I never got the tachometer to work (gave up long ago) even though Matt was amazingly patient and even sent me replacement parts. I may revisit this some day. Don't forget to remove the plate that is associated with the tachometer. It is the round disc affixed to the spindle with a simple slotted set screw.

0008_zps56ba2e63.jpg

There are four (4) socket head cap screws holding the motor in place. I removed those and left the mounting plate affixed to the motor. Be careful not to lose the key. Below is the motor removed and the key in place.

0009_zps60695939.jpg

Here is where the motor shaft and key are inserted into the gear box head/cover.

0010_zpsc8d8ca54.jpg

Next come the six socket head cap screws that hold the cover on the gear box. Forgive the out of focus picture. What you can't make out are two locating pins. This makes it oh so fun when pulling the head/cover off of the gear box. Oh, and there are a few other things that you will come to understand that make pulling the cover off.

0011_zps218185cf.jpg

Next up is the cover on its top and the gear train displayed.

0012_zps593b031d.jpg

Does this look different than the other threads? YES IT DOES. This is where the fun began for me. More on this to come. The pictures you see in some other posts do not have all four (4) gear shafts in place. Three pieces were found after draining the oil from the head. Here they are:

0014_zps7eeb3c65.jpg

Above are a gear from the shaft that is directly turned by the motor, the key for that gear, and the lever bracket. The lever bracket is what pushes the gears between low, middle, and high gear ranges. Here is a better picture of the lever bracket.

0016_zpsc5567319.jpg

Here is a picture of where the lever bracket sits followed by the lever bracket in place on the lever rod. It s not affixed in any way. It just sits on the post.

0017_zps64992b79.jpg

0018_zps5120ca30.jpg

This is what took some trial and error in figuring out how to put this beast back together. If some of the pictures look out of sequence, they probably are. I had this thing apart several times and wound up doing two (2) oil changes before successfully getting ti back together. I would recommend removing the two middle gear shafts at this point.

Here is the first shaft removed from the cover. Take note of the teflon tape around the gear that is rotated by the motor. I put two layers on the shaft and that got the gear to remain in place during assembly. Until I did that, that stupid gear fell off. It took about six (6) times of that nonsense before I gave up, dropped back, and punted. What the pictures do not show is that I trimmed the excess after the gear was in place.

0019_zps1a739c2a.jpg

These are just other shots at a slightly different angle. I did not bother to take pictures of the second shaft removed. I figured it is enough to say remove the middle two and let it go at that. Oh, and have fun removing them. They do not just slip out of the bearings. That was a pain in itself. I had to use a clamp to grip the shaft and then cantilever the shaft upwards. Yeah, it sounds simple. It took about half an hour and much cussing to get it done. And let's not even discuss how I came to the conclusion that these two shafts have to come off in order to reassemble the mill. That in itself will get my blood pressure rising and require me to drink heavily.

0020_zpsa9162908.jpg

0021_zps7c6adf89.jpg

Next up in our little story is the gear shaft that controls the gear speed ranges. The lever bracket actually sits between the gear and the "non gear" on the shaft. There are positive detents for the gears to sit in place.

0022_zpsa8c69b3b.jpg

Now on to the gear box itself. Here we can peer into the abyss.

1000_zpsc3d484f6.jpg

1001_zps527ccf76.jpg

Next up is where the oil level sits in comparrison to the oil pointer (viewing window).

1002_zps57c91eac.jpg

Here is where the oil is in relation to the spindle seals. You only see one as they are stacked on top of each other.

1003_zps3416e9ac.jpg

Next I undid the drain plug on the underside of the gear box and let the oil drain out.

1004_zps96a9db82.jpg

1005_zps42480d21.jpg

Sludge, sludge, and more sludge!

1006_zps40c01703.jpg

1007_zpsc68c5f76.jpg

Cleaned out!

1008_zps6a48c041.jpg

Should I be concerned about this?

1008a_zpsc92bc9d1.jpg

Now on to why we are here in the first place. Here I have the spindle seals removed. Have fun with that. I used a sharp 1/4" chisel to cut the seals and then I pried up a corner until I could grab it with a pair of long nosed needle nosed pliers.

1009_zps20e77a7b.jpg

1010_zps90d18a67.jpg

If you go back to the beginning of the post and look at the seals I was sent by Matt, you will notice that there are two disticnct sides. The cup side goes down. I say this because that is how it was for the two that I removed. I put the first one in place and tapped it into place a little bit at a time until it was flush with the casting. Then I used a 6mm socket screwdriver to fit in the grooves of the spindle and tapped slighlty one groove at a time until it was fully seated. I then repeated that process with the second seal.

1012_zpscd6d7e88.jpg

I forgot to take pictures of the two middle gear shafts being put in place but I did take a little video showing it in action with the gear range selector. First is a picture of the two gear shafts in place.

1015_zps0ddf2066.jpg


[video]http://vid1379.photobucket.com/albums/ah152/topsecretsecurity/Mill%20Spindle%20Seal%20Change/1015_video_zps2rcarwhs.mp4[/video]


Time for oil! This is one of those times that the pictures do not match the story. Do not fill with oil at this time. Finish the gear assembly and then replace the drian plug and fill from the top at the fill point.

1016_zps6c73ed02.jpg

Two (2) quarts in...

1017_zpsf35e22b7.jpg

Three (3) quarts in....and enough.

1018_zps1288ec74.jpg

Here is the view from the sight.

1019_zps05b0c76b.jpg

Notice the cleaned off box lip. I cleaned off the cover as well and used a liquid sealant.

1020_zps3ab78d60.jpg

Some final notes that you cannot show in pictures. The gear shafts are quite the press fit. I had to get everything lined up and then use a dead blow hammer to go around the outer edge of the cover and tap it down into place. I put all of the screws back in and then went through a modified break in cycle. I did low gear at the lowest speed for 15 minutes. I then did it for the fastest speed in the lowest gear for 10 minutes. I repeated that for the middle gear range. Finally, I did 5 minutes at the lowest speed in the high range.

I hope this helps. I also hope that I never have to do this again. I really think that if I have a slow leak again, I will be OK with that and just keep an eye on the oil level. If it gets a bit too low I will drain it and then refill.

One final note. I used teflon plumbers tape on the oil drain plug and the oil fill plug.

Elliott

0001_zps6481168f.jpg


0001_zps6481168f.jpg


0001_zps6481168f.jpg


0002_zps18c04e6f.jpg


0002_zps18c04e6f.jpg


0002_zps18c04e6f.jpg


0003_zpsc095a497.jpg


0003_zpsc095a497.jpg


0003_zpsc095a497.jpg


0004_zpsa2942b71.jpg


0004_zpsa2942b71.jpg


0004_zpsa2942b71.jpg


0005_zps7379d737.jpg


0005_zps7379d737.jpg


0005_zps7379d737.jpg


0006_zpsfce7a31f.jpg


0006_zpsfce7a31f.jpg


0006_zpsfce7a31f.jpg


0007_zpsad265121.jpg


0007_zpsad265121.jpg


0007_zpsad265121.jpg


0008_zps56ba2e63.jpg


0008_zps56ba2e63.jpg


0008_zps56ba2e63.jpg


0009_zps60695939.jpg


0009_zps60695939.jpg


0009_zps60695939.jpg


0010_zpsc8d8ca54.jpg


0010_zpsc8d8ca54.jpg


0010_zpsc8d8ca54.jpg


0011_zps218185cf.jpg


0011_zps218185cf.jpg


0011_zps218185cf.jpg


0012_zps593b031d.jpg


0012_zps593b031d.jpg


0012_zps593b031d.jpg


0014_zps7eeb3c65.jpg


0014_zps7eeb3c65.jpg


0014_zps7eeb3c65.jpg


0016_zpsc5567319.jpg


0016_zpsc5567319.jpg


0016_zpsc5567319.jpg


0017_zps64992b79.jpg


0017_zps64992b79.jpg


0017_zps64992b79.jpg


0018_zps5120ca30.jpg


0018_zps5120ca30.jpg


0018_zps5120ca30.jpg


0019_zps1a739c2a.jpg


0019_zps1a739c2a.jpg


0019_zps1a739c2a.jpg


0020_zpsa9162908.jpg


0020_zpsa9162908.jpg


0020_zpsa9162908.jpg


0021_zps7c6adf89.jpg


0021_zps7c6adf89.jpg


0021_zps7c6adf89.jpg


0022_zpsa8c69b3b.jpg


0022_zpsa8c69b3b.jpg


0022_zpsa8c69b3b.jpg


1000_zpsc3d484f6.jpg


1000_zpsc3d484f6.jpg


1000_zpsc3d484f6.jpg


1001_zps527ccf76.jpg


1001_zps527ccf76.jpg


1001_zps527ccf76.jpg


1002_zps57c91eac.jpg


1002_zps57c91eac.jpg


1002_zps57c91eac.jpg


1003_zps3416e9ac.jpg


1003_zps3416e9ac.jpg


1003_zps3416e9ac.jpg


1004_zps96a9db82.jpg


1004_zps96a9db82.jpg


1004_zps96a9db82.jpg


1005_zps42480d21.jpg


1005_zps42480d21.jpg


1005_zps42480d21.jpg


1006_zps40c01703.jpg


1006_zps40c01703.jpg


1006_zps40c01703.jpg


1007_zpsc68c5f76.jpg


1007_zpsc68c5f76.jpg


1007_zpsc68c5f76.jpg


1008_zps6a48c041.jpg


1008_zps6a48c041.jpg


1008_zps6a48c041.jpg


1008a_zpsc92bc9d1.jpg


1008a_zpsc92bc9d1.jpg


1008a_zpsc92bc9d1.jpg


1009_zps20e77a7b.jpg


1009_zps20e77a7b.jpg


1009_zps20e77a7b.jpg


1010_zps90d18a67.jpg


1010_zps90d18a67.jpg


1010_zps90d18a67.jpg


1012_zpscd6d7e88.jpg


1012_zpscd6d7e88.jpg


1012_zpscd6d7e88.jpg


1015_zps0ddf2066.jpg


1015_zps0ddf2066.jpg


1015_zps0ddf2066.jpg


1016_zps6c73ed02.jpg


1016_zps6c73ed02.jpg


1016_zps6c73ed02.jpg


1017_zpsf35e22b7.jpg


1017_zpsf35e22b7.jpg


1017_zpsf35e22b7.jpg


1018_zps1288ec74.jpg


1018_zps1288ec74.jpg


1018_zps1288ec74.jpg


1019_zps05b0c76b.jpg


1019_zps05b0c76b.jpg


1019_zps05b0c76b.jpg


1020_zps3ab78d60.jpg


1020_zps3ab78d60.jpg


1020_zps3ab78d60.jpg
 
Hey Elliott,
Excellent post, thank you for that!

I did one a while back, and if I remember right, the shafts came right out of the top bearings and stayed in the lower part of the gearbox, so didn't have quite the same trouble, but like I said it has been a while, so I don't remember the exact details.

But that is great and thanks for the information here!
 
Added to sticky archive.
 
good job photographing the project, it will be very handy for reference if I have to replace my seals.
steve
 
Nice job, pretty nasty oil/sludge on the bottom. Some drain plugs have a strong magnet built in (or can be added), so attracts the metallic the filings to a point. With all the sludge and particulates, it is a good reason to change the oil shortly after break in. I also had a lot less foaming and picked up some top end speed, after changing the original gear oil to a high quality synthetic gear oil.
 
Nice job, pretty nasty oil/sludge on the bottom. Some drain plugs have a strong magnet built in (or can be added), so attracts the metallic the filings to a point. With all the sludge and particulates, it is a good reason to change the oil shortly after break in. I also had a lot less foaming and picked up some top end speed, after changing the original gear oil to a high quality synthetic gear oil.
Thanks for bringing up the magnets. I meant to put one in but completely forgot. I was just so happy that I got the thing back together and it worked. I had never changed the oil so I was expecting the sludge. Mea culpa, mea culpa, mea maxima culpa. During the break in I did not notice a lot less foaming in the sight glass. I also noticed how much quieter the mill is. Unfortunately I don't know one brand of oil from another. Matt told me to use 85W90 so that is what I bought at the local automotive parts store. They only had that one brand so that is what I wound up with. If anyone has a better brand, please post it with why it is better. I'd love to know a bit more about that subject; but not enough to write a dissertation. ;) Elliott
 
Matt recommended me to use the same oil as I do in my lathe which is Mobil DTE Heavy Medium (ISO 68). Grizzly also recommends ISO 68 for their RF-45 style mills. I'm in Socal & it doesn't get cold here, I may even be fine using ISO 100 in the hot summer days. I buy the Mobil DTE from Enco or my local MSC but any industrial supplier should carry it or the equivelent (basically hydraulic oil).
 
Yegg,

im down the road from you in fredericksburg, was at autozone the other day looking for oil for my mill and did not find any, where parts store did you find that?

lanham
 
Yegg,

im down the road from you in fredericksburg, was at autozone the other day looking for oil for my mill and did not find any, where parts store did you find that?

lanham

I bought it at Fairfax Auto Parts (NAPA) right around the corner from my house. They had a case on the shelf. It was 10 and change per quart.

Elliott
 
These are pretty light duty milling machines, but at the end of the day, they may benefit from a mainstream oil designed for this specific application. The most common is the Mobil DTE series circulating oil or their stabilized hydraulic oil. In a mill gearhead, either the Heavy-Medium (ISO 65.1, SAE 20 or gear Oil SAE 80) or Heavy (ISO 95.1, SAE 30 or gear oil SAE 85) are probably the most appropriate. Note that there are different ISO/SAE depending on the application, see chart. Enco carries these Mobil oils in 1 Gallon containers, when on sale with free UPS shipping, you are looking at $25 per container delivered. I would follow the manufactures recommendation on the ISO grade to use, it may vary somewhat if depending on your climate temperature and speeds you commonly use.

My BF-30 specifies ISO 100, but with a 3000 RPM top end, you can run into a lot of gear train drag from the oil with the high viscosity. The standard Rong Fu gearhead mills that I have seen use ISO 68 (SAE gear oil of ~80). I ended up with a synthetic 75-90W gear oil, so starts out a bit thinner, but holds it viscosity a bit better when it gets hot. I use an oil specific to gear drives, not car differentials. I do not know if it presents an issue, but most auto store gear oils are designed for differentials, so they have different additives and properties, especially those used for limited slip. Car engine oils are not recommended as gear oils because of the detergent used.

Lathe headstock and gearbox/carriage apron gearbox may be a bit different, Grizzly and many small-medium lathe manufactures often recommend an ISO ~32 oil for the headstock (DTE24 stabilized hydraulic oil ISO 32, SAE 10; or their DTE Light), and an ISO ~68 for the the gearbox/carriage apron gearbox. Lathes tend to have larger headstock gears then mills, using a higher ISO oil then recommended would cause significantly more frictional drag as the RPM is increased. So Mobil oil DTE24 or DTE light (ISO 32), and DTE26 or DTE heavy/medium (ISO 68). The Shell oil equivalents would be the Tellus 32 and 68 (see cross reference chart).

Oil Cross Reference Chart.jpg Oil Viscosity Charts.jpg
 
Back
Top