I have a strong preference for roller bearing steady rest, and am working out a design for an 8" capacity steady rest for my Monarch. I didn't get the original with the lathe, but a smaller rest on a spacer that is rather light and is only about 4" capacity.
If you have chip control problems, it may be that you aren't breaking chips properly, or have the rest too close to the end of the work. I have, when this problem presents itself, taken a coffee can lid (plastic), and fashioned a guard of sorts to keep the stringy chips away from the rollers.
If you are creasing the OD, you are too tight. That can happen when you are cutting of you allow the material to get too hot and expand. That also can cause ID egging. Bearings selected for steady rests are semi-spherical OD races, so they don't leave too big a track. Properly adjusted, they leave very little marking, unlike solid tipped rests.