Tachometers with hall proximity sensor question

Keep in mind that if you mount the magnet on the step pulley, it won't read the correct spindle speed when using the back gears... you will have to reduce the reading by the ratio of the back gear reduction.

-Bear
 
Keep in mind that if you mount the magnet on the step pulley, it won't read the correct spindle speed when using the back gears... you will have to reduce the reading by the ratio of the back gear reduction.

-Bear
This is exactly why I asked this question. I thought I had my answer,but now I am not so sure anymore. I have three pulleys in there,the drive stack,idler and spindle stack. I have the belt on the pulleys that will produce 1300rpm max currently and vary the speed via external potentiometer on my vfd. Where can I put the magnet if there isn't a suitable spot on the spindle to give me the precise spindle speed at any given time? If pictures will help,I can take some tomorrow,but from what I know, there is no place to mount the magnet other that on the spindle pulley.
 
As long as you are on the spindle stack you will get the correct RPM reading. The motor pulley stack and idler pulley stack configurations with the belt will determine how fast the spindle stack turns yes. But one revolution of the spindle stack is still 1 RPM of the spindle. If you put the magnet on the motor stack or the idler stack you will not get accurate spindle RPM. Picture would help but as long as you are on spindle stack all info above should be spot on.
 
Ok but what about what Bear said in post #11,or am I misunderstanding what he is saying?
 
Ok but what about what Bear said in post #11,or am I misunderstanding what he is saying?
I can’t speak for bear. Can only assume he thinks the magnet is going on the motor stack or idler stack? He will need to jump in and clarify. I am 100% confident that putting the magnet on the spindle stack will give you spindle RPM. The back gears just control the speed of that spindle stack. Larger pulley slower and smaller pulley faster. Think of it this way, I have my lathe magnet mounted on a collar on my lathe spindle. It does not matter what gear ratio I apply to my head stock gears. And it made no difference what size collar was on my spindle or if I mounted directly to the spindle. The magnet reads 1 revolution each time past the sensor whether geared to 43 RPM or 2000 RPM. If I put the magnet on the motor pulley it would read 1800 RPM for the motor no matter what gear the lathe was in or what speed the spindle went.
 
Last edited:
How you now explained it is how I understood it the first time,so yes Bear would have to jump in explain what he meant....please.
 
How you now explained it is how I understood it the first time,so yes Bear would have to jump in explain what he meant....please.
Your spindle pulley stack should be keyed to your spindle shaft so the stack and shaft have to be going the same RPM.
 
I'll be more specific. You want your magnet mounted on the spindle. It is the spindle rotation that you are concern with. If you mount the magnet on any gear or pulley other than the spindle, you will get a RPM reading of that gear or pulley that probably is not the spindle RPM.
 
I'll be more specific. You want your magnet mounted on the spindle. It is the spindle rotation that you are concern with. If you mount the magnet on any gear or pulley other than the spindle, you will get a RPM reading of that gear or pulley that probably is not the spindle RPM.
So since the OP plans to mount the magnet to the spindle pulley stack that is keyed to the spindle shaft. The RPM reading will be the RPM of the actual spindle correct? This is what he is trying to get a consensus on.
 
Back
Top