Subscribed with great interest Ray,
On the whole "neat" scanner thing that's advertised on TV, maybe I just don't get it, but it's not like your going to actually throw away originals of important documents, I don't see the piles going away...while it might be nice for business cards or non critical paperwork, I just don't see the point.
As we get more digital, please remember a backup! I use Carbonite myself, the piece of mind it provides is worth every penny to me. I tried the whole external drive thing, but was never disciplined enough to do regular backups...I always told myself "I'll do it tomorrow" or some other such excuse. Having the data (and pictures) off site incase the unthinkable happens is also reassuring.
I agree with your critique of the Neat Scanner. It solves the end of the problem that wasn't the main issue to begin with.
With regards to backup, the best system is the one you will actually use! Having said that, after several system rebuilds from the Windows install disks, I use Acronis with an external hard drive. Every Sunday morning, I just got done as a matter of fact. Then quarterly I burn an image to a BluRay disk. Looking after my computer and my wife's takes about 1 to 1.5 hours weekly. I've retrieved two lost files for her and saved everything from a burned out cpu + motherboard. That one resulted in about 3 days of lost email, but it could have been much, much worse.
Walt